1983 First Team: Phil Pohlman, O.C. Hughes

1984 Honorable Mention: Phil Pohlman, Jerome Taylor, Nick Lawless

1985 Honorable Mention: Phil Pohlman, Nick Lawless

1986 Honorable Mention: Nick Lawless

1987 First Team: Brian Becker

Honorable Mention: Mike Carter

1988 First Team: Scott Crowder, Tony Cox, Brian Becker

Honorable Mention: Jeff Little, Tim Keane, Bob Crawford

1989 First Team: Scott Crowder, Steve Boss, Brian Becker

Honorable Mention: Jamie Gorman, Ted Rumler

1990 First Team: Steve Puck, Mark Grounds

1991 Honorable Mention: Sean Hickerson

1992 First Team: Brooks Beck, James Johnson, Rodney Flowers

Second Team: Carlton Goff, Vince Richardson, Blair Ackman, Sean Hickerson

1993 First Team: James Johnson, Chad Slagle, Scott Puck

Second Team: Heath Bowman, Scott Germain, Karl Peters, Rodney Flowers, Carlton Goff

1994 First Team: Rodney Flowers, Chad Slagle, George Murphy, Heath Bowman

Second Team: Brad Young, Carlton Goff

1995 Second Team: Paul Reynolds, Aaron Marshall, Nate

1996 Second Team: Jason Downs, Ryan Livesay

1997 First Team: Joe Bulla, Josh Patrick, Dave Showman

Second Team: Jason Downs, Kevin Kinnee, Matt Hoots

1998 Second Team: Kevin Kinnee

Honorable Mention: Dane Wear, Corey McFarlane, Tim Wagenbach, Chad Lamb

1999 First Team: Patrick Bowman, Dane Wear

Honorable Mention: Derek Leonard, Jared McCammon, Josh Patrick

2000 First Team: Patrick Bowmam

Second Team: Derek Leonard, Ryan Van Aken, Mike Watson, Rich Stott

Honorable Mention: Nolan Leever, Jared McCammon, B.J. Harvey, Bobby Brents, Bobby Noll, Glenn Weatherford

2001 First Team: Patrick Bowman, Willie Thompson

Second Team: A.J. Vassar

Honorable Mention: John Allison, Erik Karhliker, Derek Leonard, B.J. Harvey, Rich Stott

2002 First Team:Willie Thompson and B.J. Harvey

Second Team: Ryan Van Aken, Dustin Devening and Andy Wagenbach

Honorable Mention: Thompson, Harvey, Greg Lowder, Chris Weller, Dan Holden, Rich Stott

2003 First Team: Willie Thompson;

Second Team: Adam Bruns;

Honorable Mention: Dustin Devening, Brian Short, Jeff Edmonds, B. J. Harvey

2004 First Team: Brian Short, Willie Thompson (as DL and P), Jeff Whiteside;

Second Team: Jarid Crain, Joe Horeni, Joe Reed;

Honorable Mention: Jim Cowgill, Kyle DeGroot, Jon Howard, Scott Lanthrip, Mitch Wilson

2005 First Team: Joe Horeni, Jim Cowgill;

Second Team: Jarid Crain, Jon Howard, Kyle DeGroot;

Honorable Mention: Brad Linares, Jeff Edmonds, Pete Vaughn, Rob Woodward, Michael Miller, Ryan Little

2006 First Team: Joe Reed, Tim Shields, Jon Howard (as return specialist);

Second Team: Pete Jennings, Jon Howard (as wide receiver), Rob Woodward, Jason Murphy;

Honorable Mention: Brad Linares, Aaron Taft, Antwan Byrd, Jake Weller